born and raised
I’m the daughter of a pastor, colloquially known in some Christian circles as a PK. I freakin’ hate that abbreviation. Some people wear it like a badge of honour, some people use it to belittle and box-in. There are plenty of reasons to hate the label and that’s why I’ve never applied it to myself or to anyone else to whom it may apply.
My experience is quite atypical of that of many children of clergy, actually. Growing up in the church is a difficult and precarious thing for any kid, whether her parent is the pastor, the moderator, the women’s ministries coordinator, the pianist, the organist, whatever. When I look back on my childhood, I think the difficult aspects of the church stemmed from that sort of general involvement rather than the fact that my dad was the pastor.
Like I said, my experience is not typical. I lucked out and spent most of my growing-up years in a remarkably functional church, where there was little discord. Whatever there was my parents successfully hid from me. My brother and I were treated well. I’ve heard stories about other clergy kids being told things like, “You’re the pastor’s son/daughter, you have to set an example.” No one ever said that to me. Or if they did, I blocked it out of my memory because it’s complete bullshit.
When I look back on my life, being a pastor’s kid meant mostly one thing: presents.
When I was two, we moved out to a parsonage in the country. The rambling house was right next to the church, in the midst of wheat and barley fields cut into squares by gravel roads. My mom was in the middle of a difficult pregnancy, so on Christmas Eve she didn’t attend the service. But after the service, the doorbell started ringing, various parishoners seeking an audience. Not to chide her for her non-attendance (after all, physician-ordered bedrest is an excuse even the most religious can abide). No, they wanted to drop off the presents, for me. Granted, I was a really adorable (if moody) child, but that Christmas Eve set a precedent for years to come. Basically, being the pastor’s kid meant getting special treatment. More attention, more love. And it really was love — presents are nice, but I always felt that people cared about me, and even as a kid I knew that was more important than trinkets.
I never really had any pastor-kid friends until I went to bible school — there, four of my closest friends were children of clergy, and because the school was a denominational one, two of them had lived in the very same rural parsonage I had. In fact, one still did live there. It was super cool to go there on weekends and eat real food and sleep in the basement where I had watched countless hours of Mr. Dressup and built blanket forts with my brother.
Anyway, I don’t think my experience was much different from that of any kid with very devout parents. Which is good, I guess.
Sometimes I wonder what makes one church-raised kid rebel/resist their religion and others not. What makes one person able to incorporate their history and childhood faith into an adult one? Why is it for some a seamless transition, and others not?
In my case I wonder if it’s just flat-out a personality issue. I’m a cranky bitch, always have been. “Strong-willed” is the term, I believe. Though, I’d like to think my struggle with/against Christianity is about more than some kind of inborn antipathy.
Part of me has always been jealous of the people for whom faith is so easy. For whom religion is easy. The people whose eyes close tight in prayer and you know they really believe, that the structures and the symbols all make sense to them.
As a kid, I was always waiting for, praying for that moment when it would be the same way for me. But now I don’t think that moment will ever come, and I have to be OK with that — I have to accept it. Which is harder than it sounds.
February 12th, 2006 at 4:02 pm
wow jenny. thanks. as a pastor with kids, it gave me a lot to think about. maybe even more so because of the church you refer to that i know so well. and i don’t think faith is ever easy for people… they just become good at faking it or minimalizing it. real faith is always hard.
February 13th, 2006 at 2:28 pm
Yeah, I envy the fact that you didn’t feel the pressure to “set an example”. I did. And as one who had gone from being a pastor’s kid to a pastor’s wife, I am feeling the freedom now that Dylan’s not employed by one particular church. Of course, he couldn’t stop being a pastor any more than he could stop breathing… But that’s one of the many things I love about him.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I appreciate it, and you.
February 13th, 2006 at 5:22 pm
Word up B & D. I realized reading Dylan’s comment that all the people he lives with are pastors’ kids! Heh. Funny how things work out. I, like your girls, am a second-generation pastor’s kid, as well… fascinating how these things happen.
When it comes to the Church We Know So Well, I wonder how things would have turned out had we stayed there longer… maybe I would have ended up feeling more pressure? I don’t know. Though I don’t know, I still don’t get nothing but love from those people, even 20 years later. Stu and Jan still send me birthday money every year. Of course, like I said, presents =/ love, not always anyway. Love is sitting with my mom while my dad was in open-heart surgery for 6 hours, like Jan did a few years ago. Love is making sure I got settled in when I left home for the first time, and so on.
ANYWAY. I love you both. The end.
February 13th, 2006 at 5:23 pm
I also remember Christmases at the parsonage… looking back on it now, it’s quite incredible what those people would do for their pastors. I don’t think I had a good grasp of it at the time though.
And yeah… I dunno about the whole rebelling thing… I guess I’m not one to rock the boat (at least, not overtly.
) But I certainly don’t feel comfortable with a lot of the baptist/evangelical traditions/attitudes. And sometimes I even convince myself that this equals a weaker faith on my part…
I think the somewhat strange thought for me is that if I hadn’t grown up in a Christian home, I would very likely not be a Christian today. In fact, I’d probably consider myself “far too intelligent” for something like that and look upon it with condescension. So by all rights, I should be rejecting it, except for the traditional place within my life. It’s a bit of a puzzle, yes.
February 13th, 2006 at 7:51 pm
Hey Jenny,
I just started reading your blog. I really agree with your comment about being jealous of those who can just believe. Thanks for pointing Dylan to Stupid Church People because he pointed me to it… I like it.
Miss you lots. Let’s do nuggets some time.
February 14th, 2006 at 5:51 pm
When reading this, I couldn’t help but think of children from different families in the Bible and how their offspring turned out: Adam and Eve’s kids, David’s kids, Solomon’s kids, etc. Yowza.